For years, the idea of fully automating customer service has been a tech industry talking point. With the rise of generative AI and conversational bots, some predicted a near-future where call centers would be replaced entirely by machines. But if you were expecting Fortune 500 companies to go all-in on automation, recent research suggest that future may be farther off than expected.
In fact, Gartner now predicts that by 2028, zero Fortune 500 companies will have eliminated human customer service agents entirely.
That’s right, none. Not a single one.
Why the Agentless Future Isn’t Coming
There’s been no shortage of bold claims about AI replacing jobs. Even OpenAI’s CEO, Sam Altman, has recently suggested that entire job categories, such as customer service, might disappear. But Gartner’s latest data tells a different story.
By 2027, half of the companies that had planned to significantly cut their customer service teams due to AI will likely abandon those plans.
Why? Because going completely agentless just isn’t working out.
Companies that tried aggressive automation strategies are already rehiring human agents, often because the AI solutions couldn’t handle the complexity, or the customers pushed back.
What AI Can (and Can’t) Do Well
AI is doing a lot of good. It’s excellent at handling routine, repetitive tasks. It can answer basic questions, retrieve account information, and resolve straightforward issues more quickly than a human ever could.
But when things get tricky, think emotionally charged situations, exceptions to the rules, or high-stakes problems, AI often falls short. It might misunderstand the customer, hallucinate a solution, or fail to escalate appropriately. And unlike a human, AI can’t recognize when someone’s about to churn or when empathy is what’s really needed.
That’s where human agents shine.
They can listen, interpret tone, adapt in real time, and de-escalate when something’s gone wrong. They offer the kind of judgment and contextual awareness that AI hasn’t mastered, and may never fully replicate.
From Cost Center to Growth Driver
So what should companies do instead? Gartner recommends that companies focus not on eliminating agents, but on redeploying them to more strategic, value-driven roles.
Rather than viewing service roles as purely reactive or expendable, forward-thinking organizations are shifting those same agents into higher-value work: resolving complex cases, guiding at-risk customers, cross-selling, creating knowledge content, or even helping train AI systems. With AI taking over the basic tasks, human agents can focus on what really drives growth and customer loyalty.
This is already happening.
Gartner’s research shows that while only 11% of companies have reduced their frontline headcount, 54% have used GenAI tools to scale service operations without adding more people.
That’s the winning formula: more coverage, better service, same or fewer people.
It’s Time to Rethink “Efficiency”
For CIOs and support leaders, the focus should shift from replacing human agents to enhancing their capabilities through technology.
That means rethinking workforce planning, redefining service roles, and investing in systems that support collaboration between AI and human agents.
You’ll still want automation, no doubt.
But you’ll also want strong fallback mechanisms, escalation paths, and human oversight, especially for complex or high-stakes interactions.
It’s also a reminder to shift your metrics.
Instead of focusing solely on resolution time or call deflection, look at metrics like customer lifetime value, retention rates, and upsell effectiveness. These are the kinds of outcomes human agents, especially when supported by smart AI, can directly influence.
Human Agents Are Your Safety Net
One reason this hybrid model is so important is risk management.
AI, even when highly trained, can still make mistakes, especially when it’s dealing with incomplete or unexpected inputs. In regulated industries or sensitive situations, a poorly timed or inaccurate AI response can create real damage. Human agents serve as a safety net, helping mitigate those risks.
They’re also vital for relationship management.
When something goes wrong, it’s the human who can reassure, adapt, and make a customer feel heard. That’s vital when it comes to protecting your brand.
The Wrap
So no, the agentless future isn’t right around the corner, and according to Gartner, it may never arrive at all for the largest companies.
The more likely scenario is a future where humans and AI work together, each doing what they do best.
For CIOs and tech leaders, that means shifting from a “cut costs” mindset to a “drive value” strategy. Use AI to handle the basics, and let your human agents elevate the customer experience where it really counts.
Companies that get this balance right will keep their customers happier, and they’ll be better positioned for long-term growth.
It’s not humans versus AI, it’s humans plus AI. That’s where the real opportunity is.
Trusted insights for technology leaders
Our readers are CIOs, CTOs, and senior IT executives who rely on The National CIO Review for smart, curated takes on the trends shaping the enterprise, from GenAI to cybersecurity and beyond.
Subscribe to our 4x a week newsletter to keep up with the insights that matter.
